نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Abstract
This study aimed to identify the challenges and shortcomings of school-based educational programs designed to foster the internalization of prayer in schools in Zahedan, Iran, and to propose effective strategies for enhancing their effectiveness. The central research problem was the gap between the formal implementation of prayer-related activities and the development of students’ positive attitudes, intrinsic motivation, and sustained commitment to prayer. The study was applied in purpose and employed a mixed-methods approach using a sequential exploratory design. In the qualitative phase, 24 participants—including school principals, extracurricular and educational affairs coordinators, teachers, school counselors, congregational prayer leaders, students, parents, and educational science faculty members—were recruited through purposive maximum-variation sampling and participated in semi-structured interviews. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis. In the quantitative phase, 20 experts in religious education, curriculum planning, educational management, and school-based educational affairs evaluated and prioritized the strategies identified in the qualitative phase through a three-round Delphi process. Eight categories of challenges were identified: content-related shortcomings; implementation and management weaknesses; challenges associated with teachers and educational staff; student-related factors; family and environmental influences; cultural, media-related, and social factors; deficiencies in evaluation and feedback; and limited appeal and opportunities for student participation. Redesigning content to reflect students’ developmental stages and needs, building the capacity of school personnel, actively involving students, and strengthening home–school partnerships received the highest priorities. The findings indicate that the internalization of prayer cannot be achieved merely by increasing the number of prayer-related activities or monitoring students’ attendance. Rather, it requires the coordinated redesign of educational content, instructional approaches, human resources, the learning environment, and evaluation systems.
Introduction
Prayer occupies an important place in Islamic education, not merely as a religious obligation but also as a potential means of fostering spiritual awareness, self-regulation, moral responsibility, and religious identity. From an educational perspective, however, the effectiveness of school-based prayer programs cannot be assessed solely by the number of ceremonies held or students attending congregational prayers. A more meaningful assessment considers whether students develop an understanding of prayer, a positive attitude toward it, a sense of personal meaning, intrinsic motivation, and sustained commitment.
The internalization of prayer involves a gradual transition from externally regulated participation to a personally meaningful and relatively enduring commitment. This process is influenced by multiple interacting factors, including the relevance of educational content, the quality of instructional approaches, the behavior and competencies of school personnel, students’ developmental needs, family involvement, peer relationships, the wider cultural and media environment, and the availability of appropriate evaluation and feedback mechanisms.
Previous research has examined various aspects of religious education, including curriculum content, teachers’ roles, family–school cooperation, students’ religious attitudes, and the use of participatory methods. Nevertheless, the simultaneous interaction of these factors in school-based programs for promoting prayer requires further investigation. In particular, the distinction between participation in formal activities and the internalization of religious values needs to be addressed more explicitly.
Accordingly, this study investigated the challenges affecting school-based programs intended to promote the internalization of prayer in Zahedan and sought to develop and prioritize practical strategies for improving their effectiveness. Its central contribution lies in examining these challenges as an interconnected educational and organizational issue rather than attributing them to a single factor.
Case study
The study was conducted in schools in Zahedan, Sistan and Baluchestan Province, southeastern Iran, during the 2024–2025 academic year (1403–1404 in the Iranian calendar). This setting provided an opportunity to examine prayer-related educational programs through the experiences and perspectives of individuals directly involved in school-based religious education.
The qualitative participants represented a range of educational and social roles, including school administrators, educational affairs coordinators, teachers, counselors, congregational prayer leaders, students, parents, and faculty members in educational sciences. This diversity enabled the study to consider the issue from multiple perspectives and to explore the relationships between school practices, student experiences, family contexts, and broader cultural influences.
The study focused on the design, implementation, and evaluation of school-based programs intended to promote prayer. It examined both the challenges encountered in practice and the strategies that experts considered important and feasible for addressing them. The findings are context-specific and should therefore be interpreted with due consideration of the educational, cultural, and organizational conditions of the participating schools.
Materials and Methods
The study was applied in purpose and employed a sequential exploratory mixed-methods design. The qualitative phase preceded the quantitative phase: the first phase identified the major challenges and generated potential strategies, while the second phase used expert consultation to evaluate and prioritize those strategies.
In the qualitative phase, 24 participants were recruited through purposive maximum-variation sampling. Variation was sought in relation to school levels, gender composition, and differences between more advantaged and less advantaged school contexts in Zahedan. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews, supplemented by the review of relevant policy documents and field notes. Interviews explored the current state of prayer-related programs, content and implementation challenges, the roles of school personnel and families, the quality of prayer facilities, and existing evaluation practices. Sampling continued until theoretical saturation was reported.
The interview data were analyzed using inductive thematic analysis, following the six-phase approach of Braun and Clarke: familiarization with the data, generation of initial codes, development of candidate themes, review of themes, definition and naming of themes, and report production. MAXQDA 2024 was used to support data organization and coding. The resulting themes were organized into broader categories representing the principal challenges affecting the programs.
In the quantitative phase, 20 experts were purposively selected on the basis of relevant academic qualifications and professional, executive, or research experience. Eligibility criteria included at least a master’s degree in a related field and a minimum of five years of relevant experience. The Delphi process consisted of three rounds. Experts assessed the proposed strategies using a five-point rating scale and considered their necessity, effectiveness, practical feasibility, and implementation priority.
The Delphi data were analyzed in IBM SPSS Statistics 29 using means, medians, standard deviations, percentage agreement, the interquartile range, and Kendall’s coefficient of concordance. The reported criteria for accepting strategies and concluding the Delphi process included a mean score of at least 3.75, agreement of 75% or higher, an IQR of no more than 1, and evidence of stability and convergence across rounds.
Qualitative rigor was addressed through credibility, transferability, dependability, and confirmability. The reported procedures included participant review of findings, the use of multiple data sources, transparent documentation of the research process, and review of selected interviews and initial codes by three specialists in qualitative research. The content validity of the Delphi questionnaire was examined using the content validity ratio (CVR) and content validity index (CVI). Internal consistency was assessed using Cronbach’s alpha, reported as 0.87.
Discussion and Results
The qualitative analysis identified eight major categories of challenges affecting school-based programs for promoting the internalization of prayer.
First, content-related shortcomings included repetitive and formulaic messages, insufficient adaptation to students’ developmental stages, an emphasis on theoretical instruction, formal or unengaging language, and limited connections between prayer and students’ everyday concerns. These findings suggest that the mere inclusion of prayer-related information in educational activities is insufficient when content does not engage students’ cognitive, emotional, and practical experiences.
Second, implementation and management weaknesses included the intermittent and occasion-based delivery of activities, inadequate planning, limited coordination among school personnel, insufficient time, and weak managerial support. These problems indicate that prayer-related programs may lack the continuity and organizational coherence needed to support sustained educational outcomes.
Third, limitations in teachers’ and educational staff’s competencies involved insufficient communication and educational skills, inadequate specialized training, limited participation by some teachers, and weaknesses in role modelling. The findings highlight the importance of respectful communication, the ability to engage with students’ questions, and consistency between educators’ stated values and their everyday conduct.
Fourth, student-related challenges included declining intrinsic motivation, perceptions of prayer-related activities as compulsory, superficial participation, and a mismatch between program formats and students’ interests and expectations. These findings underline the importance of distinguishing externally prompted attendance from meaningful engagement and personally endorsed commitment.
Fifth, family and environmental influences included insufficient family engagement, inconsistent educational practices between home and school, differences in family backgrounds, and inadequate prayer facilities. The findings suggest that school-based efforts may be constrained when they are not supported by constructive relationships with families and an appropriate physical and psychological environment.
Sixth, cultural, media-related, and social factors included the influence of digital media, changing lifestyles, peer environments, and competition from more engaging forms of communication and entertainment. These factors point to the need for educational approaches that communicate with students in relevant formats without reducing religious education to entertainment alone.
Seventh, deficiencies in evaluation and feedback included the absence of appropriate indicators of educational effectiveness, an emphasis on reporting activities and attendance, superficial monitoring, and limited use of feedback to improve program design. Counting ceremonies or attendance may document implementation, but such measures cannot independently establish changes in students’ attitudes, motivation, or sustained commitment.
Eighth, limited appeal and student participation reflected the dominance of one-way, lecture-based activities, a lack of variety, insufficient opportunities for student input, and limited use of creative approaches. Meaningful student involvement may help programs become more responsive to students’ needs and strengthen their sense of agency and responsibility.
The Delphi process was used to evaluate and prioritize strategies developed from the qualitative findings. The four highest-priority strategies were redesigning program content to reflect students’ ages and needs, strengthening the competencies of teachers and educational staff, increasing meaningful student participation, and improving home–school partnerships. Other proposed strategies included using creative and media-based approaches, improving prayer facilities, establishing more informative evaluation and feedback systems, and strengthening ongoing managerial support.
The reported increase in Kendall’s coefficient of concordance from 0.41 in the first round to 0.69 in the third suggests increasing agreement among the expert panel. The reported decline in the IQR from 1.42 to 0.81 also indicates reduced dispersion in expert ratings. These results support the conclusion that expert judgments became more convergent across the Delphi rounds.
Taken together, the qualitative and quantitative findings suggest that the challenges are interconnected. Content redesign is unlikely to be sufficient without capable and supportive educators, coherent implementation, meaningful student involvement, family engagement, appropriate facilities, and an evaluation system that informs continuous improvement. The findings also suggest that program effectiveness should be assessed using a broader set of indicators, including students’ perceived meaning of prayer, satisfaction with their experiences, voluntary participation, attitudes, and continuity of behavior beyond formal school activities. These indicators are proposed as directions for evaluation rather than outcomes directly measured by the present study.
Conclusion
This study identified eight interconnected categories of challenges affecting school-based programs designed to promote the internalization of prayer in Zahedan. The findings indicate that the main issue is not simply the availability or number of prayer-related activities, but the extent to which their content, delivery, organizational support, and educational environment are aligned with students’ developmental needs and experiences.
The expert panel prioritized age- and needs-appropriate content redesign, capacity-building for school personnel, meaningful student participation, and stronger home–school partnerships. These priorities point toward a coordinated and context-sensitive approach in which religious education is designed as an ongoing educational process rather than a series of isolated activities. Schools may benefit from conducting local needs assessments, assigning clear responsibilities, supporting educators’ communication skills, involving students in program design, engaging families as educational partners, and using evaluation findings to revise activities.
The study is limited by its focus on schools in Zahedan and its reliance on participants’ accounts and expert judgments. The proposed strategies were prioritized through expert consensus; their actual effects on students’ attitudes, intrinsic motivation, and long-term commitment were not directly tested through an intervention or longitudinal design. Future research could compare different school contexts and evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed strategies over time. Quantitative studies could also examine the relationships among program quality, student participation, intrinsic motivation, and sustained engagement in prayer.
Overall, the findings support a shift from activity-centered implementation toward a coherent, participatory, and evidence-informed approach to school-based religious education.
کلیدواژهها English